Perhaps no Arab is better known as a public intellectual than the great late Arab American scholar Edward Said, whose writings and lectures resonated across the world. Said once wrote: "The role of the intellectual is not to consolidate authority, but to understand, interpret and question it."
In the Gulf Arab states, the public intellectual is often a misunderstood entity; for some reason, it is confused with self-congratulatory sentiment and pretentiousness. Public intellectuals in the Gulf are also often associated with the government or state-backed media. Even in a good case, many can be considered government spokesmen. In bad cases, intellectuals can be accused of having links to outside powers or groups, a label that is almost impossible to shake off in the Arab world. The notion of an independent public intellectual has yet to figure prominently in the common Gulf Arabic vernacular.
Sadly, in recent months there have been arrests and intimidation of public intellectuals in the Gulf. In one Gulf state, a professor was detained for writing an article questioning his country's political future; in another, a lawyer was jailed for highlighting financial connections related to a government official. Both of these are legitimate concerns and independent thinkers deserve to be honoured, not persecuted, for dealing with them.
Gulf states do not need to be anxious as the intellectual sphere expands. In some cases, public intellectuals offer a platform for debate between government and citizens through their activities, columns and discussions. Gulf intellectuals also serve as a bridge between their countries and the outside world, often writing in international newspapers and offering an independent perspective on events within these countries.
Gulf governments and societies alike should be proud of the intellectual capacity that is building in these young nations. Often it will be these intellectuals who defend emerging states in the international media, lobby for their causes at conferences and promote their agendas. During the invasion of Kuwait, for example, public intellectuals played a major role in promoting the cause of liberation in the global media. When Dubai was targeted by a harsh media campaign last year, Emirati intellectuals stepped up to defend it. During the run up to Qatar's Fifa World Cup bid, young Qataris lobbied heavily on social media for the bid. Young Saudi intellectuals are active on new and traditional media outlets, defending their country but not shying away from criticising aspects that they would like to see improved.
The significance of this growing group of intellectuals, whether they act on behalf of their governments or on their own, should not be underestimated. The value to society of these lawyers, scholars, columnists and professors stems from the fact that they have an independent critical thinking process. Independent public intellectuals provide a much needed critique of society as well as of government plans and expenditures. Public intellectuals reflect the conscience of society and should not be regarded as a threat, but as part and parcel of the community. More often than not, they are concerned with the advancement of society.
Ideally, a healthy balance of liberal, secular and religious public intellectuals should be allowed to flourish so that Gulf societies can advance in a stable manner. In the majlis of Abu Dhabi's Crown Prince Sheikh Mohammed bin Zayed as well as in certain dewaneyas in Kuwait, intellectuals of various backgrounds from across the world are feted and given a platform to share their thoughts. If the leadership in the UAE understands the role of intellectuals, members of society at large and other government officials should enlighten themselves. Independent public intellectuals are a complementary voice to governments in the Gulf.
As long as intellectuals are not affiliated with foreign organisations or other countries, they should not be seen as a threat but as an opportunity for regional governments to communicate with their people, especially in countries that lack effective parliaments. More often than not, the concerns raised by public intellectuals are justified and are best dealt with head on.
Public intellectuals also carry a responsibility to their country, not to allow themselves to become pawns in the hands of exterior powers or fall under foreign influence. They must understand that reform should be encouraged and not artificially enforced; after all, the prosperity in the Gulf states is in no small part due to government policies.
The understanding, interpretation and questioning that public intellectuals carry out are the essence of humanity. These traits are what have led leading global innovators, entrepreneurs and inventors to make their greatest discoveries. Finally, Gulf leaders should ponder the following: was Edward Said a threat or an asset?
*This article first appeared in The National on Sunday 12th December 2010
Showing posts with label gcc. Show all posts
Showing posts with label gcc. Show all posts
Sunday, 12 December 2010
Monday, 6 December 2010
A Collection of Citizen Voices Urges the GCC to Cooperate
Every year, Gulf citizens collectively hold our breath, hoping that a specific 24-hour period ends in a better way than it started. This day starts tomorrow at the Gulf Cooperative Council summit in Abu Dhabi, where the last leg of the Formula One Grand Prix was held last month. But unlike the competitors in that race, we can all emerge winners from this upcoming event.
It is no secret that the aspirations of Gulf citizens far exceed the achievements of the council. Recently I attempted to capture some of these aspirations using new social media forums. On Twitter, I posed the question: "What do Gulf citizens want from the summit?"
Here are some of the many comments I received: Barrak al Babtain from Kuwait, clearly concerned about the environment, responded "abolish fuel and electric subsidies, invest heavily in public transportation". From Qatar, Raed al Emadi commented that he would like to see education and health-care budgets as big as those allocated for arms deals.
In Bahrain, Yacoub al Slaise wants a bullet-train network between GCC countries and better joint cultural and education programmes. From the same country, Saud Albuainain wants to see strict enforcement of civil laws.
A post from an Emirati who goes by the handle AlBaron11 requested that leaders give Gulf women the right to pass their nationality on to their children "especially if the father is from GCC". Another UAE writer known as Al Emarati asked for elected local councils that could vote for a unified Gulf council as well as tackling the population imbalance.
Clearly these are major demands, but what the GCC has already accomplished should not be discounted. Today, most Gulf citizens are able to visit each other's countries carrying only an ID card. One example of the benefits of this system could be seen in bilateral relations between the UAE and Saudi Arabia. Citizens could cross the border easily until a disagreement prompted Riyadh to withdraw the facility, although the UAE graciously continued to allow Saudi citizens to cross. Perhaps the expected attendance of Prince Nayef bin Abdul Aziz, the Saudi interior minister, in Abu Dhabi tomorrow will pave the way for the ID card agreement to be reintroduced.
Although it was launched in 2003, the Gulf Customs Union is still facing "administrative hurdles" according to Mohammed al Mazroui, the GCC assistant secretary general for economic affairs. Even so, trade between GCC countries jumped from $30 billion (Dh110.2 billion) each year prior to the customs union to more than $70 billion today.
In tomorrow's meeting the $20 billion Gulf-wide railway network spanning the six states is likely to receive the green light for completion by 2017, although it is not certain that it will be bullet trains as Mr al Slaise hopes.
The future of the Gulf currency union, which has been one of the main discussion points of meetings over the past decade, is almost certainly decided. The withdrawal of Oman and particularly the UAE, which had previously championed the currency union, dealt a severe blow to the plan. The crisis facing Europe's common currency means any mention of a common currency tomorrow would be only in passing. But that should not dampen hopes that there are many other areas where we can cooperate.
I would also like to propose the creation of a Gulf Joint Embassy project similar to the Nordic Embassy in operation in Berlin since 1999. Denmark, Finland, Iceland, Norway and Sweden have saved money and other resources, finding synergies by grouping together under one umbrella in the German capital. As in the case of the Nordic countries, Gulf culture, cuisine, history, music and other traditions could be promoted jointly across the world hand-in-hand with diplomacy.
A system patterned after the Schengen Agreement could also be introduced for Gulf states for those willing to participate. Already Qatar and Oman have introduced a joint tourist visa for nationals of 33 countries, allowing them to travel freely between states. Perhaps this visa could be extended to other willing GCC countries. Another project in place already allows GCC expatriate residents in certain professions to visit other Gulf countries for one month.
In another area, unifying investment laws for foreigners would certainly encourage foreign direct investment into the region, which decreased last year to $50 billion after a peak of $60 billion in 2008.
The challenges that Gulf countries face are very similar across a diverse spectrum. We all must find jobs for young people, limit environmental degradation, confront Islamophobia, improve education standards, protect the rights of immigrant labour, and face a host of emerging challenges that include food and water security. All of these issues can best be addressed collectively.
Gulf citizens will hope to see practical steps incorporated in next Tuesday's communique because this summit will signal the work of the coming decade. The Gulf street is holding its breath, and the onus is on our leaders to deliver.
*This article first appeared in The National on Sunday, 5th December 2010
It is no secret that the aspirations of Gulf citizens far exceed the achievements of the council. Recently I attempted to capture some of these aspirations using new social media forums. On Twitter, I posed the question: "What do Gulf citizens want from the summit?"
Here are some of the many comments I received: Barrak al Babtain from Kuwait, clearly concerned about the environment, responded "abolish fuel and electric subsidies, invest heavily in public transportation". From Qatar, Raed al Emadi commented that he would like to see education and health-care budgets as big as those allocated for arms deals.
In Bahrain, Yacoub al Slaise wants a bullet-train network between GCC countries and better joint cultural and education programmes. From the same country, Saud Albuainain wants to see strict enforcement of civil laws.
A post from an Emirati who goes by the handle AlBaron11 requested that leaders give Gulf women the right to pass their nationality on to their children "especially if the father is from GCC". Another UAE writer known as Al Emarati asked for elected local councils that could vote for a unified Gulf council as well as tackling the population imbalance.
Clearly these are major demands, but what the GCC has already accomplished should not be discounted. Today, most Gulf citizens are able to visit each other's countries carrying only an ID card. One example of the benefits of this system could be seen in bilateral relations between the UAE and Saudi Arabia. Citizens could cross the border easily until a disagreement prompted Riyadh to withdraw the facility, although the UAE graciously continued to allow Saudi citizens to cross. Perhaps the expected attendance of Prince Nayef bin Abdul Aziz, the Saudi interior minister, in Abu Dhabi tomorrow will pave the way for the ID card agreement to be reintroduced.
Although it was launched in 2003, the Gulf Customs Union is still facing "administrative hurdles" according to Mohammed al Mazroui, the GCC assistant secretary general for economic affairs. Even so, trade between GCC countries jumped from $30 billion (Dh110.2 billion) each year prior to the customs union to more than $70 billion today.
In tomorrow's meeting the $20 billion Gulf-wide railway network spanning the six states is likely to receive the green light for completion by 2017, although it is not certain that it will be bullet trains as Mr al Slaise hopes.
The future of the Gulf currency union, which has been one of the main discussion points of meetings over the past decade, is almost certainly decided. The withdrawal of Oman and particularly the UAE, which had previously championed the currency union, dealt a severe blow to the plan. The crisis facing Europe's common currency means any mention of a common currency tomorrow would be only in passing. But that should not dampen hopes that there are many other areas where we can cooperate.
I would also like to propose the creation of a Gulf Joint Embassy project similar to the Nordic Embassy in operation in Berlin since 1999. Denmark, Finland, Iceland, Norway and Sweden have saved money and other resources, finding synergies by grouping together under one umbrella in the German capital. As in the case of the Nordic countries, Gulf culture, cuisine, history, music and other traditions could be promoted jointly across the world hand-in-hand with diplomacy.
A system patterned after the Schengen Agreement could also be introduced for Gulf states for those willing to participate. Already Qatar and Oman have introduced a joint tourist visa for nationals of 33 countries, allowing them to travel freely between states. Perhaps this visa could be extended to other willing GCC countries. Another project in place already allows GCC expatriate residents in certain professions to visit other Gulf countries for one month.
In another area, unifying investment laws for foreigners would certainly encourage foreign direct investment into the region, which decreased last year to $50 billion after a peak of $60 billion in 2008.
The challenges that Gulf countries face are very similar across a diverse spectrum. We all must find jobs for young people, limit environmental degradation, confront Islamophobia, improve education standards, protect the rights of immigrant labour, and face a host of emerging challenges that include food and water security. All of these issues can best be addressed collectively.
Gulf citizens will hope to see practical steps incorporated in next Tuesday's communique because this summit will signal the work of the coming decade. The Gulf street is holding its breath, and the onus is on our leaders to deliver.
*This article first appeared in The National on Sunday, 5th December 2010
Tuesday, 22 September 2009
Challenges for Private Equity in the GCC
Entrepreneurs in the oil-rich Gulf have many challenges to overcome that begin with raising the required capital for their businesses. In this wealthy region, one may wonder why Gulf investors shy away from private equity, where all of the angel investors are.
It is, in fact, not possible to say that Gulf investors or even expatriates based in the region shy away from risky investments. Over the past few years, we have all seen real estate buyers purchase property that cannot be registered in their names from developers who have no established history delivering projects. We have also seen these same buyers borrow money from banks and place a down payment on a unit in order to flip it in the not-too-distant future. All of the elements show that investors have been ready to go into risky territory.
A similar pattern has been noticed in the stock market, where investors purchase stocks of companies that are overpriced without conducting any due diligence on the company’s background, including its management and the PE ratio of the stock itself. So why aren’t we witnessing the same pattern with the private equity industry in the region?
The first issue that must be noted is the lack of avenues for investors to find such potential projects and for entrepreneurs to locate such investors. In fact, most entrepreneurs that I have come across who have not raised money from immediate family and friends have done so by a complete serendipitous coincidence. Freej, a very popular UAE-based animated cartoon series, was funded because a colleague of the show’s creator saw the creator’s sketches on his workstation while fetching a document and shared the drawings with their boss. The creator tells me that when he was called into to the boss’s office, he thought he was in trouble for drawing. His boss, however, encouraged him and introduced him to potential investors. Freej turned out to be the most successful programme in the country.
In Dubai, the Sheikh Mohammed Bin Rashid Establishment for Young Business Leaders has been very successful in funding projects by young Emiratis. The centre, however, does not fund projects by non-nationals, even though there is a majority expatriate population. This circumstance leaves a large gap in the private equity niche that should be filled as soon as possible. Many expats have the proper education and commitment to see small business grow into large corporations. We saw such incidences happen across the Gulf in the 1970s and 1980s through joint ownerships with Gulf nationals. Other institutions in the UAE that offer private equity include Mubadala, National Bank of Abu Dhabi and the Sheikh Khalifa Fund. Gulf Finance House and Al Baraka in Bahrain also have units dedicated to PE, as does Kuwait Finance House.
Proper legislation must be introduced to protect the rights of both parties. ‘Intellectual property rights’ is a notion that is still developing in the Gulf, although it has been recognised recently as an essential part of an entrepreneur sharing his or her ideas with an investor.
Often, an entrepreneur will share an idea with someone who has a network of potential investors that can be approached for funding.
Non-governmental developments in the past few years have also assisted in the emergence of this nascent but essential industry, such as the creation of the Gulf Venture Capital Association, a non-profit trade and industry association that promotes a risk-taking investment culture and provides information on the VC/PE industry by organising conferences and training workshops.
Clearly, funding isn’t a challenge in the GCC. A report published recently by Merrill Lynch Global Wealth Management stated that in 2008, the number of dollar millionaires in Saudi Arabia stood at 91,600. In the UAE, the number was 67,100. The report also stated that financial wealth in the Middle East stood at US$1.4 trillion last year and is expected to rise to US$1.9 trillion in 2013. The challenge remains in finding a way to channel the money to budding entrepreneurs.
With the recently released Arab Human Development report estimating that the Arab world needs to create 50 million new jobs by 2020, access to private equity funding will need to be streamlined and institutionalised. The regional governments cannot possibly create that many jobs on their own, so a large part of this challenge will rest on the shoulders of young entrepreneurs who will need to find the right investors at the right time.
There is a need for early-stage funding of projects in the Gulf. Whether they are started by national or expatriate elements, or a combination of both, is a secondary issue at this stage. In the end, it is the Gulf that will benefit from a boom in this industry.
*This article first appeared in Moneyworks magazine in the September issue.
It is, in fact, not possible to say that Gulf investors or even expatriates based in the region shy away from risky investments. Over the past few years, we have all seen real estate buyers purchase property that cannot be registered in their names from developers who have no established history delivering projects. We have also seen these same buyers borrow money from banks and place a down payment on a unit in order to flip it in the not-too-distant future. All of the elements show that investors have been ready to go into risky territory.
A similar pattern has been noticed in the stock market, where investors purchase stocks of companies that are overpriced without conducting any due diligence on the company’s background, including its management and the PE ratio of the stock itself. So why aren’t we witnessing the same pattern with the private equity industry in the region?
The first issue that must be noted is the lack of avenues for investors to find such potential projects and for entrepreneurs to locate such investors. In fact, most entrepreneurs that I have come across who have not raised money from immediate family and friends have done so by a complete serendipitous coincidence. Freej, a very popular UAE-based animated cartoon series, was funded because a colleague of the show’s creator saw the creator’s sketches on his workstation while fetching a document and shared the drawings with their boss. The creator tells me that when he was called into to the boss’s office, he thought he was in trouble for drawing. His boss, however, encouraged him and introduced him to potential investors. Freej turned out to be the most successful programme in the country.
In Dubai, the Sheikh Mohammed Bin Rashid Establishment for Young Business Leaders has been very successful in funding projects by young Emiratis. The centre, however, does not fund projects by non-nationals, even though there is a majority expatriate population. This circumstance leaves a large gap in the private equity niche that should be filled as soon as possible. Many expats have the proper education and commitment to see small business grow into large corporations. We saw such incidences happen across the Gulf in the 1970s and 1980s through joint ownerships with Gulf nationals. Other institutions in the UAE that offer private equity include Mubadala, National Bank of Abu Dhabi and the Sheikh Khalifa Fund. Gulf Finance House and Al Baraka in Bahrain also have units dedicated to PE, as does Kuwait Finance House.
Proper legislation must be introduced to protect the rights of both parties. ‘Intellectual property rights’ is a notion that is still developing in the Gulf, although it has been recognised recently as an essential part of an entrepreneur sharing his or her ideas with an investor.
Often, an entrepreneur will share an idea with someone who has a network of potential investors that can be approached for funding.
Non-governmental developments in the past few years have also assisted in the emergence of this nascent but essential industry, such as the creation of the Gulf Venture Capital Association, a non-profit trade and industry association that promotes a risk-taking investment culture and provides information on the VC/PE industry by organising conferences and training workshops.
Clearly, funding isn’t a challenge in the GCC. A report published recently by Merrill Lynch Global Wealth Management stated that in 2008, the number of dollar millionaires in Saudi Arabia stood at 91,600. In the UAE, the number was 67,100. The report also stated that financial wealth in the Middle East stood at US$1.4 trillion last year and is expected to rise to US$1.9 trillion in 2013. The challenge remains in finding a way to channel the money to budding entrepreneurs.
With the recently released Arab Human Development report estimating that the Arab world needs to create 50 million new jobs by 2020, access to private equity funding will need to be streamlined and institutionalised. The regional governments cannot possibly create that many jobs on their own, so a large part of this challenge will rest on the shoulders of young entrepreneurs who will need to find the right investors at the right time.
There is a need for early-stage funding of projects in the Gulf. Whether they are started by national or expatriate elements, or a combination of both, is a secondary issue at this stage. In the end, it is the Gulf that will benefit from a boom in this industry.
*This article first appeared in Moneyworks magazine in the September issue.
Labels:
angel investors,
dubai,
gcc,
gulf states,
private equity,
uae
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)